What Do You Call a Benevolent and Reasonable Person in Xianxia? An Impossibility! (BTTH)

The central idea underlying this fanfiction is centered on the hypothetical scenario of what could... Read more
The central idea underlying this fanfiction is centered on the hypothetical scenario of what could have happened if the individual who experienced reincarnation as Xiao Yan is a genuinely compassionate, ethical, and morally upright person hailing from the modern society, despite losing the memory from his past life yet still retain his personality and belief.And well, turn out you would be much more liked by everyone else. Collapse

Alchemy, Battle Academy, Beast Companions, Cultivation, Fanfiction, Male Protagonist, Mythical Beasts, Pill Concocting, Reincarnated in Another World, Spirit Advisor, Wars, Weak to Strong, Battle Through the Heavens

There is no reasonableness in it and it is not expected.

Now that we got to this point I will kindly request someone who actually read btth to tell me what tang San did as a person that everyone hates himP.S. I am not defending his actions nor understand them. I genuinely do not know what he did I only read up to the Poseidon arc and most of that was skimming the manwua not the novel

im pretty sure Tang San is from different series called daloulu dalao (pretty sure i write it wrong cant remember and too lazy)the protagonist of BTTH is called Xiao Yan or something (sorry im bad with names)

You are right

You are right I was confused and mixed up the characters the mc of btth was the the dude with the ring and the ancestor in it right?

Yes , he was called Xioa Yan

Is he the hated protag?

Not really, he's kinda neutral, while he's not that likable but not to the point people will hate him like other Chinese protagonists for example Yun Che or Tang San is also bad

Fair enough is Yun che from agaist the heavens?

smoov Che is from ATG

Against the gods?This stuff is all kinds of messed upWho is the guy everyone hates how is okay so many questions yet none know

Well, I read a little and for Xiao Yan. It was mainly because his cultivation was higher than other, and became the de-facto boss among the youth. I think he was also a pretty well known fighter so he challenged and humiliated many kids.Then the ring thing his mother gave him started suck away his cultivation. His enemies he defeat and just people wanting to gain confidence by beating him started to use him as a punching bag.If you were asking about irl people hating him, idk, I kinda turned my brain off and read, if you wanted a meta-answer, its to give him a reason for being stronger, no one wants or likes being on the end of bullying, so it motivates him to get strongerThis is all just based on my understanding of the book.

Real.

Well yeah because most of the nice people are mostly dead.

Seems kinda nice, but I haven't even read BTTH yet and likely never will, it seems to have a lot of the tropes, though to be fair it was to some degree a trend-setter, so you can't exactly blame it either. Still, not my cup of tea, but xianxia fanfictions are really getting popular these days, huh? We seem to have one with every release!

Well the novel name sound too BTTHHmmJoin the ranobe discord, link in my

What Do You Call a Benevolent and Reasonable Person in Xianxia? An Impossibility!You are goddamn right

What about those kind villagers that are gonna be slaughtered in the next 10 chapters?

Shhhhh no let's not talk about them

Thats why its impossible... If you are kind you will be slaughtered in at most the next 10 chapters

I've seen a few that sorta fit the bill - Lan Luo from Absolute Resonance is both reasonable and sort-of 'benevolent', though in a human sense not godly which that word always seems to imply, and Bai Xiaochun was pretty nice, too?...I mean he seems pretty nice from an outsider's perspective who never has to actually deal with him or his pill making, but I'd say it still counts.